Hoyt Mansion, Hoytsville Utah

by Karri Dell Hays

 

Blanche Crittenden Brooks daughter of William Earl & Nettie Lavina Crittenden Brooks was born here 24 Mar 1910
 
   

It is well known that the history of our beautiful state is tightly woven with the Mormon religion. Scattered around the state are bits and pieces of their precarious beginnings. In the small town of Hoytsville, which lies just a few miles south of Coalville there resides a large, hand-dressed sand stone structure that housed one of the first members of the Mormon faith.

<Hold mouse over picture for color photo.

  Samuel P. Hoyt was a devoted follower and friend to Joseph Smith back in the days when Nauvoo, Illinois was home to the Mormon Church. Hoyt, originally from Chester, New Hampshire, was sent on a mission to Massachusetts before ending up in Utah in 1851. Hoyt spent a brief time in Fillmore, Utah where he helped build the never completed Territorial Capitol building. Hoyt left Fillmore by order of then Mormon Church President, Brigham Young to a town called Unionville in the Weber Basin. Years later the town would be re-named in his honor for bringing prosperity and recognition to the small community.

Today, the Samuel P. Hoyt house may seem small compared to the super-sized Deer Valley homes that loom over Park City, but in 1863, it was most definitely considered a mansion. Three stories hold thirteen rooms and nine fireplaces. In the basement Hoyt built a well that current residents say is still working and is used to this day.

Hoyt spared no expense in making his home a near work of art. Current residents, Harold and Martha Donaldson shared stories about the murals of cherubs, cornucopias and different designs painted by a Norwegian man named Olsen on many of the walls and ceilings. "Along the stairs they had painted the walls to look like wood," said Mrs. Donaldson. Unfortunately, due to the settling effects of the house the plaster that these hand painted murals covered, fell and were replaced with modern materials.

Rounded, stone archways, elaborate chimneys and fireplaces were designed to fit with the Gothic looking Georgian style that was popular in the mid 19th Century.

Adjacent to the house are stone ruins where Hoyt built Summit County’s first flour/grist mill. The mill provided a valuable resource as well as employment for the growing community. The mill only survived for four years, as there was not enough fall in the water flow to provide the power needed to run the machinery.

Hoyt persevered however. He started a carding mill, which also closed due to low power source and he opened a grocery store. Later, Hoyt became most prosperous in the cattle ranching, mining and farming industries. For a time, two rooms on the third floor of his private residence housed a school for the community. Hoyt’s first wife, Emily Smith Hoyt, otherwise known as "Ma" Hoyt was the teacher. Two of Hoyt’s daughters from his second wife, Emma Burbridge, lived in the house with ‘Ma’ Hoyt when she became crippled with rheumatoid arthritis.

In 1866-67 the settlers of the Weber Basin were at odds with the native people in the area, it was called the Black Hawk War. During this time many of  the residents tore down their log homes and re-built them together in a square fort-style pattern within the large rock walls that Hoyt had constructed around his property. The wall was believed to be as high as seven feet in portions and was topped with the same fine, white, sculptured sandstone that graced his home.

Martha Donaldson’s parents eventually purchased the home from Hoyt’s two daughters, Elizabeth "Libby" Stonebreaker and Mary Leeds. The two inherited the house from Ma Hoyt after they had stayed to care for her when Mr. Hoyt moved to Marion with his second wife, Emma.

The Hoyt Mansion is considered to be one of the most elegant 19th Century homes still standing in Utah today.